This review appeared in Jahrbücher für Geschichte Osteuropas, Vol. 73, No. 2, December 2025. Translation by Deep-L

Derek Sayer

Postcards From Absurdistan. Prague at the End of History

Woodstock, Oxfordshire: Princeton University Press, 2022. XIX, 730 pp., 81 ill.

ISBN: 978-0-691-18545-3.

This book is a kaleidoscope and an adventure. A declaration of love and a tour de force. A narrative of Czech and German—but also Jewish—language and culture, of yesterday and today, art and philosophy, ideology and everyday life, happiness and pain. Derek Sayer describes the coexistence, the confusion, the connections, the conflicts, and the violence. The wealth of knowledge gathered here across more than 750 pages of text is impressive. The author demonstrates a profound understanding, particularly of literature, but also of architecture, photography, and painting. His knowledge of the Czech Republic’s past and present is more than well-founded; one can really only describe it as intimate.

Under the title Postcards From Absurdistan: Prague at the End of History, Sayer thus tells stories from and about Prague, centered on individual figures, some well-known, others less so. In doing so, he begins—curiously, contrary to what is stated in the blurb, where the time period covered is listed as 1939–1989—with the turn of the 20th century. Nor is the focus on Prague maintained throughout, which enriches the book—Prague emerges as a vanishing point of modernity and as the center of a highly complex network—but here, too, the contradiction with the title is jarring. Yet Sayer begins in Prague, with the things he knows best: Franz Kafka forms the primary focus of his interest, while Kafka’s friend (presumably not his lover) Milena Jesenská is the secondary one. Through these two figures, readers are guided through Prague from the 1900s to the 1930s and get to know both the friends and enemies of Kafka and Jesenská. At times verging on kitsch of the “colorful,” diverse, wild, boozy, and also slightly gloomy Prague, yet ultimately too well-informed to succumb to clichés, Sayer depicts the city as a melting pot of the poor and the rich, Jews, Germans, and Czechs—as both the kitchen table and the cauldron of modernity.

The book’s central message, however, is ultimately found in its title: the history of Prague and Bohemia/Czech Republic is understood as “absurd.” This is broadly understandable when Sayer delightfully displays his knowledge of Czech culture—from surrealist poetry to journalistic essays or biting caricatures, all the way to the legendary Jára Cimrman. Absurdities—or things that present themselves as absurd in an attempt to conform to the cliché of “Czechness”—are plentiful. Far too much defies supposedly valid orders, whether it be the diversity of identities and languages, the delight in the surreal, or the ambitious and often rebellious childhood culture. Sayer explains his aim to describe the absurd with sarcastic jokes from the communist era (“Here we have no bananas here; it’s next door that they have no meat”), but expands the concept to encompass Czech culture from the 19th century to the present. Whether it is true that Absurdistan has “no place for kitsch” (p. 7), however, may remain an open question. For the grouping of everything Czech under the label “absurd” ultimately becomes a cliché, bordering on kitsch.

Absolutely not kitschy, but also not absurd, is the captivatingly narrated chapter on Munich, the Protectorate, and World War II. Sayer spares neither his readers nor the Czech self-image. He does not gloss over the existence of fascist forces in Czech society nor the historical distortions in the national narrative. Even anti-Semitic elements in the poems of Petr Bezruč—which belong to the canon of national literature—are not swept under the rug here. The same applies to the description of the expulsion of the population defined as German from Bohemia and Moravia after the end of the war in 1945. Sayer succeeds in clarifying the contemporary perspective and moral logic without resorting to apologetics. However, classifying this crime as “absurd” and describing it with the term “kafkárna” (defined earlier as “used to describe a nonsensical, logically inexplicable, chaotic, ridiculous, or hopeless situation” [p. 15]) borders on cynicism. It is also regrettable that Sayer portrays the denial of the expulsion crimes as still the dominant—indeed, the only—perspective in the Czech Republic. There surely could have been room for a sentence about the valuable research (e.g., by Matěj Spurný) and the highly influential fiction (e.g., by Kateřina Tučková).

And many other sections, too, ultimately do not fit under the label of the absurd. Admittedly, the situation on August 21, 1968—tanks rolling through a city that had just experienced a spring of liberation—may have seemed “absurd” to contemporaries. Nevertheless, the events, as well as the actions of both the KSČ and the party leadership in Moscow, can easily be explained rationally. The situation is quite similar with the policy of “normalization” and the social contract, which demands political restraint in exchange for an improved standard of living. Here, too, the logic and interests are understandable. The category of the absurd cannot be sustained, which also seems logical: How could an entire national history (which in and of itself is already a problematic concept in and of itself because it is essentializing) be encompassed by a single term? And thus, over the course of the book, the term increasingly becomes a cliché. It yields no analytical added value.

In general, Sayer analyzes little; he prefers to tell stories. At a breathless pace, he recounts the stories of people who, caught up in the maelstrom of events, fled from terror and sought hope, sometimes finding happiness, but often only despair or even death. Prague is the starting point, and for many, also a place of longing and return, but the city lies at the center of a network of travel routes—planned, forced, or random.

People are at the heart of this book. Often, they are women. Without necessarily making this explicit, Sayer nonetheless places great emphasis on a gender perspective and prominently incorporates the—often underestimated—role of women in the intellectual circles of the interwar period or in the dissident scene of the 1970s. The period of normalization is also largely depicted through the lives of well-known and famous figures—from gymnast Věra Čáslavská to singer Marta Kubišová to tennis player Martina Navrátilová—with anecdotes from the lives of Miloš Forman and Jan Němec. This isn’t particularly original, but it’s a thoroughly enjoyable read; Sayers’s detailed knowledge is impressive here as well.

In some chapters, Sayer’s associative narrative style reaches its limits. Among these is the integration of Prague—and even more so of nearby Kladno—into global structures, which take the protagonists—the famous ice hockey player Jaromír Jágr and his family, as well as the two architects Antonín Raymond and Bedřich Feuerstein—and thus also the readership all the way to Japan. Sayer possesses an enormous body of knowledge, but he does not always succeed in structuring it in a way that is easy to follow.

The book does not claim to tell a coherent story—rather, the lack of coherence is seen as a hallmark of modernity and a characteristic of the absurd. Instead of a single narrative thread, interconnections and networks emerge. The main characters of the first two chapters appear again and again: Franz Kafka and Milena Jesenská. The artist Adolf Hoffmeister also appears several times, as do Milan Kundera and Václav Havel. The narrative also thrives on scattered rumors and hints about who knew whom, who was friends with whom, or worked together, shared a bed, had children together, or met in a tiny Parisian apartment. This paints a picture—not entirely inaccurate—of a country where everyone knew everyone else, where the people, places, and events were intimately interwoven. The logic of this book does not stem from historiographical, theoretically underpinned theses, but rather from the relationships (and conflicts) among the protagonists and the author’s sometimes quite wild, yet always inspiring, associations.

Sayer’s work is, as already noted, a declaration of love for a country that is almost entirely identified with its intellectuals and artists; a country that is portrayed as special, in many respects even as unique. This is undoubtedly a good foundation for a fascinating and highly readable book; though not necessarily always for one that is analytically convincing.

Martina Winkler

Kiel